ADD Vendor Evaluation Deck
CTO + VP Engineering briefing 01 / 05

Slide 01

You Are About to Sit Through the Same Demo Again. Skip It.

CTO + VP Engineering + Procurement
Core claim

You have seen the demo. Your board has seen the demo. Everyone has seen the demo. A vendor who skips straight to it is not a partner — they are a closer.

If you have not seen an agent build software on YouTube, go watch it this afternoon. The demos are everywhere. AI writes code. AI finds bugs. AI generates tests. You've seen it. So why are you about to sit through it again? You scheduled this meeting hoping for a strategic conversation — to understand whether this tool matters for your situation. A vendor who jumps straight to the demo has already answered the question of how they see this relationship.

The tell "Trust me bro, this will transform your engineering org." That sentence — or any variation of it — is the signal that you are talking to someone who wants to close, not someone who wants you to succeed.

Slide 02

A Real Partner Has a Fleet of Field CTOs. Not One Overbooked Solutions Architect.

The partner signal
What you are looking for

People who have done this across financial services, healthcare, retail, SaaS. People who can pattern-match your situation to the dozens they have seen before.

They are not going to run a Big 4 reorg. But they can tell you when you are not ready. They can tell you when you are solving the wrong problem. They can say "I saw this exact thing at a healthcare company last year and here is what happened" — because they have the pattern library that only comes from doing it at scale across multiple industries.

What they can tell you When you are not ready. When you are solving the wrong problem. What has worked at similar organizations. What has failed and why. That is the conversation worth having.
Why this matters for your evaluation

A vendor with one overbooked solutions architect stretched across forty accounts cannot give you a strategic conversation. They can give you a demo and a proposal. Those are not the same thing.

The Field CTO ask is not rude. The vendor wants to accelerate your adoption just as much as you do. Getting the right people in the room from the start helps everyone. If they tell you that access is a premium service tier, they have answered the question of how strategic they intend to be with you.

Ask directly "Can we have a Field CTO or Principal Engineer join the initial call?" That is the ask. Watch the response. It tells you everything.

Slide 03

These Three Questions Are Your Prerequisites Too. Not Just Theirs.

Your side of the table
Goal

What are you trying to achieve?

If you cannot answer this before the meeting, you are not ready for a vendor conversation. You are ready for a strategic planning conversation inside your organization. Do that first. "Improve developer productivity" is not a goal you can evaluate tooling against.

Constraints

What are you actually constrained by?

Regulatory requirements. Security postures. Architectural debt. Skill gaps. Political dynamics. A vendor who asks about your constraints before showing you anything is trying to understand whether their tool can actually help. A vendor who does not ask is hoping you will find out after signing.

Current state

What is your actual SDLC today?

Not the documented one. The real one. How does a feature move from idea to production? Where does it wait? Where does it get blocked? A vendor who has seen this at scale can help you see your own system more clearly — but only if they ask.

The hard truth If you cannot answer these three questions today, that is your first problem to solve. And it has nothing to do with which vendor you choose.

Slide 04

You Can Tell Within the First Fifteen Minutes Which One You Are Talking To

The evaluation framework

The vendor (closer)

  • Leads with the demo. Every time, for every prospect, regardless of context.
  • "Trust me bro, this will transform your engineering org."
  • One solutions architect stretched across forty accounts who has not written production code in three years.
  • Tells you that strategic consultation is a premium service tier — after you have asked for it.
  • References from customers who adopted the tool, not customers who succeeded with the tool.

The partner (builder)

  • Asks about your goal, your constraints, and your current state before showing you anything.
  • Can tell you when you are not ready — and what to do about it instead of signing a contract.
  • Has a fleet of Field CTOs and Principal Engineers with industry-specific pattern libraries.
  • Has watched implementations fail and can tell you specifically why — with examples from their client history.
  • References from customers who succeeded, including what it took to get there.

Slide 05

Hope Has Never Been a Strategy. Ask the Question Before the Demo.

Decision close
The decision point

If you buy anyway — from someone who skipped the strategic conversation and went straight to the demo — you have chosen "trust me bro" over "help me think."

That is a choice you are allowed to make. But make it consciously. Know that you are betting on the demo being representative of your real situation, on the vendor's implementation support being more strategic than their sales process, on the tool being so obviously useful that it overcomes the absence of a plan for connecting it to business outcomes.

Million dollar tools gather dust when nobody connected them to actual business outcomes. The vendor has been paid. The tool sits unused. Hope was the strategy. Hope did not work.